Shelbyville, Tennessee · Saturday, November 7, 2009
[SeMissourian.com] Fair ~ 50°F  
High: 74°F ~ Low: 47°F
Print Email link Respond to editor Read comments (9) Share link

Beavers continues pre-natal care despite OB closure

Thursday, October 16, 2008

(Photo)
DR. LANA BEAVERS
[Order this photo]
Local doctor Lana Beavers says her patients will continue to receive the care they need, despite Heritage Medical Center CEO Dan Buckner's recent announcement about the hospital's intent to close its obstetrics department.

"There's nothing about my practice that has changed, except for the delivery of babies," said Beavers, who delivered 95 percent of babies born in Bedford County last year, according to Buckner. "My practice will continue to include pre-natal care."

Beavers gave notice in June that she would no longer deliver babies. Soon after that announcement became public, Heritage Medical Center terminated hospital contracts with Dr. Jan Crean and Dr. Dennis Wieck, both OB/GYNs, which was followed up two months later by Buckner's announcement of the intent to close the OB department.

Despite the hospital closing its OB department, and the fact that Beavers says she no longer delivers babies due to her age and the location of the new hospital, she's confident that her patients -- comprised mostly of indigents and TennCare recipients -- will be taken care of as a result of a working relationship that has been established between Heritage and Middle Tennessee Medical Center in Murfreesboro.

"I will continue to provide pre-natal care," said Beavers, who upon delivery time, "will make a simple phone call to MTMC. I will see them here for pre-natal care, which will save them gas money. Indigents (and Tenn Care patients) will have continuity of care. It's simply a 20-minute (further) drive for the delivery of the baby."

She said it is no different than what would take place if the OB department in Shelbyville remained open, and she were no longer delivering babies. She would still be providing pre-natal care, and another doctor would deliver the baby. Instead of going to Heritage to deliver, however, those patients will simply drive to Murfreesboro.

Beavers, who says practicing obstetrics is her passion, credits Buckner with helping arrange for the agreement with Murfreesboro.

"Without Dan and the help of the hospital I could not have continued doing pre-natal work," Beavers said. "He worked really hard to make the relationship with MTMC workable."

Beavers said she will keep Murfreesboro doctors updated on her patients' records on a weekly basis so that Murfreesboro doctors will be familiar with incoming Shelbyville patients upon delivery time.

"Now, if I didn't do pre-natal work here we would really have a problem, because a lot of (her patients) don't have the money to drive elsewhere to get pre-natal care," Beavers said.

Beavers said she wants to make it clear that her OB services are not going away. Her patients can continue to get pre-natal care, as opposed to going nine months without seeing a doctor, only to show up at the emergency room for delivery.

"Those who choose not to get pre-natal care could cause a problem," Beavers said. "They'll be provided coverage, and continuous care ... they have no excuse ... I will discourage them from waiting until the last minute."

Beavers said she understands why, under private ownership, the hospital closed the OB department.

In the 1970s, upper middle class pregnant women began receiving care outside of this county, and they have not returned.

"Those people don't have a right to complain about the OB department closing," Beavers said. "If they (middle and upper class women) aren't coming here it's not possible to stay open ... OB departments don't make money. Bigger hospitals can make up for that loss in other areas, but smaller hospitals can't absorb that cost."

Beavers said that even though the new hospital has a nicer facility, compared to the OB facility at the old hospital, there wasn't enough time to wait and see if middle and upper class women returned to deliver their babies here.

"If this hospital continued to lose money in OB, (the corporate owners) would close the hospital, and then we'd have nothing," said Beavers, noting the county opted to sell the hospital because it was not making money.

Beavers emphasized that what has happened with Heritage Medical Center is not unique to Shelbyville, and that often in smaller towns patients have to drive somewhere else to deliver their babies.

"The real losers in this situation are the (OB nurses)," said Beavers, explaining her notice to stop delivering babies may have brought the OB issue to the front burner, but that ultimately the department still, likely, would have been closed due to finances. "My decision has ultimately made them have to travel or find another field they don't like as much, and I feel bad for them. They lost the most."

Beavers said her reason to stop delivering came about due to her age and the location of the new hospital. As the doctor who was delivering most of the babies delivered in Bedford County, her schedule was grueling.

"I just don't function well on four hours of sleep anymore," Beavers said.

She will continue, however, to run her general practice on Union Street, where she focuses on primary care, pediatrics and gynecological services. She'll also continue to do some general surgery, including gynecological surgeries.

And she'll continue, as she's done for decades, to see pregnant women who don't have insurance every Wednesday at the Bedford County Health Department.

"The bottom line is that my OB patients have not been deserted," Beavers said. "They need to realize that they can get every bit of care they need here, and we have a great, solid and comfortable working relationship with MTMC where they can deliver their babies. MTMC will be very accepting of these patients."


Comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on t-g.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

Good for her!

-- Posted by knitwit6819 on Thu, Oct 16, 2008, at 12:03 PM

Personally I think the whole town would be better off without her even looking at any of the moms to be. My daughter went to her during her pregnancy and never once did Dr. Beavers do a thorough ultra sound on her. And when my grandson was born he was born with a disability we never knew about due to the fact that she didn't do the proper quality of care on my daughter to determine these problems before he was born. He had to be rushed to Vanderbilt for surgeries immediately. If the proper care had been done by her we could have been at Vanderbilt for his delivery and not have gone through all we have.

I discourage any and all people from ever going to see her for anything!

-- Posted by picmoma on Thu, Oct 16, 2008, at 1:20 PM

First of all let me say I'm terribly sorry for the problems you've had with your grandson, BUT, would an ultra sound have made a difference? It might have forewarned you, but it would have prevented the problem and the end result would have been the same. The important thing is that he got the care he needed when he was born. I'm really tired of people expecting Doctors to be miracle workers and then blaming them for every thing that goes wrong. I'm sure if she could have prevented the problem she would have, but let's face it, she's not God.

-- Posted by Imabeliever on Thu, Oct 16, 2008, at 4:09 PM

I would never expect her or any other doctor to take the place of God! That's absurd!

What she should have done was do the proper attention to detail that was needed so we would have been prepared and he could have been born in a facility where he would immediately have gone into surgery and plus the defect he was born with did have things that could have been done inutero while still being carried that could have prevented some of the damage done to his little body. So yes, she is to blame for a lot of it!

-- Posted by picmoma on Thu, Oct 16, 2008, at 4:18 PM

I'm also sorry that your grandson suffered from an unexpected illness.

Having said that, I had several ultrasounds with my second pregnancy and the birth defect that my daughter had was never detected. So, you really have no guarantee that it would have been detected, anyway.

-- Posted by Nobody'sFool on Thu, Oct 16, 2008, at 5:33 PM

I understand this doctor not wanting to continue to deliver babies, but as someone who had both my babies in less than 30 minutes with no warning ahead of time. Murfreesboro is a long drive for people like me. I think there will be lots of babies being born in the back of ambulances with the hospital no longer offering that service.

-- Posted by CD on Fri, Oct 17, 2008, at 9:21 AM

We upper and middle class women aren't going to use the hospital for other services as well, does that mean they will close the doors?

-- Posted by twocents on Fri, Oct 17, 2008, at 9:45 PM

twocents...you are absolutely correct.

-- Posted by neighborhood mom on Sun, Oct 19, 2008, at 7:31 PM

I remember many years ago just trying to find an OB-Gyn in Bedford County. Maybe if we had had more, more women would have stayed. It wasn't just the hospital. If you had a high risk pregnancy, there weren't any facilities at the hospital and there wasn't life-flight.

It looks like the hospital didn't do their research when they promoted their new, state of the art facilities, or , didn't care.

And, I agree that more babies will be born in amubulances, at home, in the back seat, or in the emergency room.

Another Bedford County accomplishment--backwards!

-- Posted by stardust on Tue, Oct 21, 2008, at 8:56 PM


Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration. If you already have an account on this site, enter your username and password below. Otherwise, click here to register.

Username:

Password:  (Forgot your password?)

Your comments:
Please be respectful of others and try to stay on topic.